The 2025 GMC Acadia and Honda Pilot are two of the most talked-about midsize SUVs on the market—but which one really comes out on top? If you’re shopping for a spacious, capable, and family-friendly vehicle in Erie, Buffalo, or anywhere across Western New York, this 2025 Acadia – Pilot comparison is your must-read guide. Whether you’re hauling gear for a weekend trip or commuting through winter roads, both the Acadia and Pilot offer strong features—but only one delivers the full package.
In this midsize family SUV face-off, we’ll break down everything from performance and towing to tech and safety. Looking for expert advice or a test drive? The team at Larry Spacc GMC is ready to help you explore the 2025 GMC Acadia up close. Contact Larry Spacc GMC and discover which SUV truly fits your lifestyle.
Which SUV Offers More for Families in Western New York?
In Erie, Buffalo, and across Western New York, the demand for midsize family SUVs is stronger than ever. These vehicles need to do it all—carry kids, cargo, and confidence through busy days and rough winters. Comfort and space are key, but safety matters just as much. Drivers here want an SUV that works hard and makes life easier.
Let’s take a quick look at the basics that matter most for busy households:
Key Family SUV Features
| Feature | 2025 GMC Acadia | 2025 Honda Pilot |
| Seating | Up to 8 passengers | Up to 8 passengers |
| Cargo Space (behind 1st row) | ~97 cu. ft. (est.) | 87 cu. ft. |
| Available AWD | Yes | Yes |
| Standard Safety Suite | GMC Pro Safety Plus | Honda Sensing |
| USB Ports in All Rows | Yes | Yes |
Three-row SUVs like the Acadia and Pilot give families the flexibility they need. Both offer space for car seats, strollers, school bags, and weekend gear. But the new Acadia stretches out a bit more this year, giving you more room in the back and a sleek new look.
What makes this comparison so important is that both SUVs are built with families in mind. But only one may truly suit yours. This Acadia vs Honda Pilot face-off is where Western New York families can start their search—and maybe even end it.
How Do the 2025 GMC Acadia and Honda Pilot Compare on Performance?
When choosing a midsize SUV, power and fuel use matter. For families in Buffalo, Erie, and across Western New York, daily drives and weekend trips call for a smooth, strong ride that’s also easy on gas. That’s where the 2025 Acadia Pilot comparison really gets interesting.
Let’s break down the engine specs and performance features that count:
Engine and Transmission Specs
| Feature | 2025 GMC Acadia | 2025 Honda Pilot |
| Engine | 2.5L Turbo 4-cylinder | 3.5L V6 |
| Horsepower | 328 hp | 285 hp |
| Torque | 326 lb-ft | 262 lb-ft |
| Transmission | 8-speed automatic | 10-speed automatic |
| Drive Type Options | FWD or AWD | FWD or AWD |
The Acadia’s turbocharged engine offers more torque than the Pilot. That means quicker takeoffs, better highway passing, and more power when you need it. In this GMC vs Honda SUV performance matchup, the Acadia brings a sportier feel.
Fuel Economy for City and Highway Use
Drivers in Buffalo and Erie spend time in both traffic and on wide open roads. Here’s how these two compare on gas use:
- 2025 GMC Acadia: Estimated up to 24 MPG highway (AWD models)
- 2025 Honda Pilot: Estimated up to 27 MPG highway (AWD models)
While the Pilot edges ahead on MPG, the Acadia balances that with stronger pull and a smooth turbo response.
Ride Comfort and AWD Performance
Western New York winters can be harsh. Icy roads, slush, and snowdrifts are part of life here. That’s why all-wheel drive is so important.
- Both the Acadia and Pilot offer AWD across most trims.
- The Acadia features selectable drive modes for snow, off-road, and towing.
- The Pilot includes Honda’s Intelligent Traction Management system.
In this 2025 Acadia Pilot comparison, both models deliver in key areas. The choice may come down to what matters more—stronger power and torque, or a slight bump in fuel savings. Either way, both are ready for the demands of Western New York roads.
Which SUV Is Better Equipped for Towing and Payload Needs?
In Western New York, many families need more than just seats and storage. They need strength. From towing boats to hauling gear for camping near Erie or Buffalo, a midsize SUV has to pull its weight—literally. That’s where towing and payload capacity come into play.
Let’s see how these two SUVs compare when it comes to real-world strength.
Towing Capacity: 2025 Acadia vs. Honda Pilot
| Feature | 2025 GMC Acadia | 2025 Honda Pilot |
| Max Towing | Up to 5,000 lbs | Up to 5,000 lbs |
| Hitch Ready | Yes (on select trims) | Yes (on select trims) |
| Tow Modes | Yes | Yes |
Both the Acadia and the Pilot offer strong towing ratings. For most families, 5,000 pounds is enough to tow:
- A medium-size boat
- A small camper trailer
- A pair of jet skis
- Utility trailers for gear or work
If towing is part of your lifestyle, either SUV can handle it. The GMC vs Honda SUV comparison here ends in a draw, but there’s more to hauling than just a trailer.
Payload Capacity
Payload is just as key as towing. It’s the weight your SUV can carry inside—passengers, bags, bikes, and more.
| Feature | 2025 GMC Acadia | 2025 Honda Pilot |
| Max Payload | Approx. 1,725 lbs | Approx. 1,660 lbs |
The Acadia offers a slight edge here. That means you can carry more people or gear without worry.
Which One Fits Your Needs in Western New York?
If your family likes to hit Lake Erie with the boat, tow a trailer for summer camping, or load up with sports gear for weekend trips, these two SUVs have the muscle.
However, the Acadia brings a little more payload strength and has a turbo engine built for tough work. When comparing GMC vs Honda SUV strength, every pound matters. And for those who live active lives in Buffalo, Erie, or the surrounding areas, that extra lift from the Acadia might make a big difference.
Is the Interior of the Acadia or Pilot Better for Your Daily Drive?
When it comes to daily life in Erie and Buffalo, your SUV’s cabin matters. This midsize family SUV face-off isn’t just about power or size. It’s also about how well each model fits your routine.
Whether it’s the morning drive to school, a commute through snow, or a weekend trip to Presque Isle, your SUV’s interior can make or break your day.
Space and Design
Both SUVs offer three rows, but space and layout feel different behind the wheel.
| Feature | 2025 GMC Acadia | 2025 Honda Pilot |
| Passenger Room | Roomy in all 3 rows | Roomy in first 2 rows |
| Cabin Feel | Premium, modern look | Clean, more basic design |
| Seating | 6 or 7 passengers | 7 or 8 passengers |
The Acadia offers a bold new design for 2025, with high-end touches and a calm, quiet ride. The Pilot leans more traditional, with large knobs and simpler lines.
Cargo Space That Works for You
The back of your SUV should handle soccer bags, groceries, and road trip gear with ease.
| Setup | Acadia | Pilot |
| Behind Third Row | About 23 cu. ft. | About 22 cu. ft. |
| With Rear Seats Folded Flat | Up to 80 cu. ft. | Up to 87 cu. ft. |
Both options deliver solid space, though the Pilot has a bit more room when all seats are down. The Acadia makes up for it with flat folding seats and smart cargo access, which many in Western New York will appreciate on busy days.
Tech Features for the Everyday Drive
Your SUV should help keep your family connected, on time, and entertained.
Acadia
- 15-inch touchscreen on most trims
- Google Built-In with maps and voice help
- Wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
Pilot
- 7- or 9-inch screen depending on trim
- Basic smartphone link features
- Lacks some of Acadia’s built-in tech
The Acadia clearly takes the edge in tech. For those commuting through Buffalo or waiting in pickup lines near Erie, these tools make life easier.
Which Cabin Wins for Daily Drives?
In this part of the midsize family SUV face-off, the Acadia shines with its large screen, quiet cabin, and upscale feel. While the Pilot offers space and simplicity, the Acadia brings style and smarter tech to each trip—whether you’re driving across town or heading out for the weekend.
Standard Safety Features: Pilot vs. Acadia
Let’s start with what comes standard. No upgrades, no extra cost—just peace of mind built in.
| Safety Suite | 2025 GMC Acadia | 2025 Honda Pilot |
| Forward Collision | Standard | Standard |
| Lane Keep Assist | Standard | Standard |
| Blind Spot Alerts | Standard | Standard |
| Rear Cross Traffic | Standard | Standard |
| Driver Attention | Standard | Included in Honda Sensing |
| Adaptive Cruise | Standard on most trims | Standard on all trims |
Both brands offer strong standard coverage. The Pilot uses its Honda Sensing suite, while the Acadia uses GMC Pro Safety Plus. In both cases, the goal is to watch the road around you and help you react fast.
Extra Safety Tech for Extra Confidence
Looking to add even more safety to your ride? These upgrades give drivers a better view and more control.
Acadia Available Features
- Head-Up Display
- HD Surround Vision
- Intersection Collision Assist
- Enhanced Automatic Parking Assist
Pilot Available Features
- Camera-based TrailWatch system (on TrailSport)
- Low-Speed Braking Control
- Multi-View Rear Camera
The Acadia goes a step further on higher trims, especially when it comes to cameras and parking help. These tools are helpful in tight spots around Buffalo or when backing out on snowy roads.
Which SUV Brings Peace of Mind?
Families in Western New York need more than just good looks and strong towing and payload. You need smart tools that help you avoid crashes and stay in control. The Pilot does a great job with basics. But the Acadia brings more advanced tech, more cameras, and new tools that fit the needs of today’s busy driver.
If safety is your top goal, the Acadia offers smart, modern help that makes every trip feel a little easier—and a lot safer.
Trim Lineup: Acadia vs Honda Pilot
Both the Acadia and the Pilot offer a range of trims built to meet different needs. Whether you’re looking for a basic family hauler or a luxury ride, both SUVs give you options.
| Model | Trim Levels |
| GMC Acadia | Elevation, AT4, Denali |
| Honda Pilot | Sport, EX-L, TrailSport, Touring, Elite, Black Edition |
- Acadia Elevation starts off the lineup with a bold look and strong standard features.
- Acadia AT4 adds off-road parts and rugged styling for adventure seekers.
- Acadia Denali focuses on upscale design, advanced tech, and premium finishes.
On the Honda side:
- Pilot Sport serves as the entry-level trim with basics like Honda Sensing and LED lights.
- EX-L and Touring add leather, larger screens, and upgraded audio.
- TrailSport is built for light off-roading.
- Elite and Black Edition bring luxury details and top tech.
Starting Prices and Value
Here’s a quick look at starting MSRPs (subject to change based on final dealer pricing):
| Model + Trim | Estimated Starting MSRP |
| Acadia Elevation | $43,000 |
| Acadia AT4 | $51,400 |
| Acadia Denali | $54,100 |
| Pilot Sport | $40,200 |
| Pilot EX-L | $43,500 |
| Pilot TrailSport | $49,400 |
| Pilot Touring | $47,500 |
| Pilot Elite | $53,080 |
| Pilot Black Edition | $54,580 |
Prices vary depending on options, drive type (FWD vs. AWD), and packages. Still, this shows that both SUVs are priced in a similar range—especially when comparing off-road and premium trims.
Which One Gives You More for Your Money?
Drivers in Erie and Buffalo want value, not just features. While both models offer strong tech and comfort, the Acadia tends to give you more at each level:
- Larger standard screen
- More advanced driver tech on mid-level trims
- Rugged off-road design with the AT4
- Premium cabin fit and finish in the Denali
In this Acadia vs Honda Pilot comparison, the Acadia gives you more upscale options sooner, with a focus on comfort, tech, and bold style—making it a smart choice for Western New York drivers who want more without jumping to the highest trim.
Which SUV Stands Out for Styling and Road Presence?
First impressions matter—especially on the road. When you line up the 2025 Acadia Pilot comparison, both SUVs have strong designs. But style goes beyond shape. It’s about how bold, clean, or rugged the vehicle looks in real life, whether it’s on a snowy side street in Buffalo or cruising down Route 5.
A Look at Exterior Design
Let’s break down the design of both SUVs. Each model brings a different feel to the table:
| Feature | GMC Acadia | Honda Pilot |
| Grille | Bold, wide, and truck-like | Smooth and more car-like |
| Headlights | Slim LED with signature DRLs | Boxy LED with basic layout |
| Body shape | Strong lines, raised profile | Rounded edges, softer stance |
| Wheel options | Up to 22 inches on Denali | Up to 20 inches on Black Edition |
| Trim accents | Chrome and gloss black (Denali, AT4) | Black-out trim on TrailSport, Black Edition |
The Acadia stands out with a wide grille and a strong, squared shape. It feels more like a rugged truck than a family van. The Pilot, while solid, leans more toward a soft, rounded look. It blends in more than it stands out.
How do powertrains of the Acadia and Pilot differ?
The 2025 Acadia uses a 2.5L turbocharged 4-cylinder engine making 328 horsepower, paired with an 8-speed automatic transmission. The 2025 Honda Pilot has a 3.5L V6 engine with 285 horsepower and a 10-speed automatic transmission.
What are their towing and payload capacities?
The 2025 Acadia can tow up to 5,000 pounds when properly equipped. The 2025 Honda Pilot also maxes out at 5,000 pounds of towing. Payload figures vary by trim, but both fall in the range of 1,500 to 1,650 pounds.
How do passenger and cargo spaces compare?
The Acadia seats up to 7 and offers 23 cubic feet of cargo space behind the third row. The Pilot also seats up to 8 and provides about 22.4 cubic feet behind its third row. Both offer over 80 cubic feet with all seats folded.
Which offers more standard safety tech?
The 2025 Pilot includes Honda Sensing on all trims, with features like adaptive cruise control and lane keeping assist. The 2025 Acadia also includes a full safety suite standard, including automatic emergency braking and lane keep assist. Both offer strong safety offerings from the base trim up.
What price ranges and trim options are available?
The 2025 Acadia comes in trims like Elevation, AT4, and Denali, with starting MSRPs around $43,000. The 2025 Pilot offers trims such as Sport, EX-L, TrailSport, and Elite, starting near $40,200.
Which SUV Should You Choose in the 2025 Acadia vs Honda Pilot Showdown?
Choosing between the Acadia and Pilot comes down to what you need day to day. Both are strong picks in the midsize SUV space, but they suit different drivers.
If you need power for towing, tough roads, or Western New York winters, the 2025 Acadia stands out. Its bold style, strong turbo engine, and off-road-ready trims like the AT4 make it a smart pick for families who do more than drive to work and school.
Drivers near Erie, Buffalo, and across Western New York can explore a wide range of new GMC models—including the Acadia—right here at Larry Spacc GMC. Our team is here to help you find a trim, price, and feature set that fits your life.
Thinking of trading in your lease? See the trade-in pros you need to weigh before making your move.
Curious how other GMC models compare to rivals? Read about the heavy-duty battle between the GMC HD and Ford Super Duty.
Want a bold off-road truck? Learn how the AT4 vs AT4X trims compare on the Sierra 2500.
No matter where you are in your shopping process, we’re here to help. Come visit us or browse online today.
Connect with us
